Trade Ledger

Every side is scored by the points those assets produced while actually sitting on the roster that acquired them. Picks are resolved to the player they became.

That number is not a verdict on the player. A pick flipped before the draft scores zero here even if it turned into a star, because the team that traded it away never got a point from it. So each asset also carries its dynasty value today, which is the other half of the story: what you gave up, whoever ended up holding it.

There is a third question, and it is the one the two managers were actually arguing about: was this fair on the day it was agreed. Every asset is priced at its real KeepTradeCut superflex value on that date, from KTC's own daily history. Grading with today's prices instead would just know the ending — DeAndre Hopkins is worth 461 now and was worth 6,039 the September he was traded — and it names a different winner on 36% of the deals here.

Career production still is not the question a manager asks when he clicks accept. That one is does my team score more points now, and it has its own answer here. Every deal is replayed: the rest of that regular season run twice off the roster as it stood, once with the trade and once without it, each week fielding the best lineup the slots allow. The per-week number under each side is the difference. Picks cannot start for you, so a deal that sends out production for capital shows red there and says so.